Search
Leave a Message
By providing your contact information to Margaret Julien, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Margaret Julien's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Margaret Julien in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Margaret Julien at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
Mediterranean-style home with an arched entry, wooden door, and mature tree.

Why Pleasure Point's Busiest Building Corridor Adds Almost Nothing for Sale

October 8, 2026

Portola Drive has more proposed housing than any other street in Pleasure Point. Between 35th and 41st Avenues, five sites are being redeveloped, waiting for review, or listed for sale. One preliminary plan calls for 168 apartments. For a buyer, the more useful question is which of these projects will ever add a home that can be bought, and the answer is close to none.

Each site's pace depends on its approval path. The paths that move fastest serve rental housing. The one project designed for ownership has spent the longest in review and would add the fewest units. A buyer comparing Pleasure Point with nearby coastal neighborhoods should expect the corridor to get busier while the number of homes for sale stays about where it is today.

Five Sites on One Stretch of Portola

As of September 2026, the sites along Portola Drive stood like this:

  1. 3501–3513 Portola Drive, at 35th Avenue next to El Rancho Center. This 1.83-acre parcel is now owned by For The Future Housing. At an August 18 community meeting, the developer presented a preliminary plan for a four-story building with 168 affordable rental units, a 55-year affordability commitment, a community room, and on-site management. The Santa Cruz Sentinel reported 192 parking spaces, with construction starting in late 2027 and finishing around 2029 if the project is approved.
  2. Pleasure Point Plaza, 3911 Portola Drive, across from SUDA. This project was approved in 2019, and the site is still a storage yard. A revised mixed-use proposal is listed by the County as a discretionary permit under review.
  3. The Lumberyard, 3800 Portola Drive at 38th Avenue. This is the only for-sale housing project on the corridor. It is also a discretionary permit under review.
  4. Back in Shape. Steve Gabay's chiropractic office and the parcel next to it are listed at $3.5 million. They have not sold, and no development applications have been filed.
  5. Portola Station, at 41st Avenue and Portola Drive. The former Opal Cliff Motors and Cliff Café buildings are being converted into a full-service restaurant and bar with patio dining. The plan adds one upstairs one-bedroom unit.

In total, these sites could add more than 200 rental units, one apartment above a restaurant, and roughly 20 condominiums that could be bought.

What the "-Min" Suffix on 3501 Portola Changes

The parcel at 3501 Portola Drive has carried C-2, Community Commercial, zoning. The County's Housing Element rezoning table lists it for a proposed change to R-UHF/RF-Min. R-UHF is Urban Flex High Residential, a land-use designation that allows 22 to 45 units per acre. RF is the Residential Flexible zone district. The "-Min" suffix is the Ministerial Combining District. County code describes RF as a district for more intensive housing along transit corridors. Multifamily housing is a permitted use, and ground-floor commercial space may be appropriate.

Ministerial review is the reason the August meeting felt different from a typical hearing. First District Supervisor Manu Koenig told the crowd at the Live Oak Community Center that state law requires unincorporated Santa Cruz County to allow 5,000 units of streamlined housing. He said the County "will not be able to vote on the project," though it will still review street access, flood zones, and health and safety. The same table proposes adding the "-Min" overlay to two more parcels on the block, 3701 and 3621 Portola Drive, while keeping their commercial zoning.

The math shows why the plan is ambitious. RF allows up to 45 units per acre, which works out to about 82 units on 1.83 acres. The 168-unit plan is roughly double that. The County's 2026 annual housing report notes that an all-affordable project can also seek density-bonus benefits under state law. The developer has not yet said which streamlining route it will use. As of Save Pleasure Point's September 8 update, no formal application had been submitted. That leaves the timeline uncertain. Even so, this is the site on the corridor with the clearest path to approval.

The 2019 Approval That Hasn't Been Built

Pleasure Point Plaza shows how the discretionary path works. The County first approved a three-story project with 33 rental units and about 7,000 square feet of commercial space in 2019. The approval was extended twice, under Permits 221363 and 231450. In November 2024, applicant A Plus Bay Plus submitted a revision for 50 units and 10,050 square feet of retail. The revision asked for a density bonus in exchange for six very-low-income rental units, plus a height increase from 40 to 41.5 feet. After review, County staff found the application "incomplete." No public meetings are scheduled, and the project cannot move forward until the applicant holds a neighborhood meeting.

Seven years after its first approval, the site is still a storage yard. Save Pleasure Point reports that the developer has shown a redrawn design but has not formally resubmitted it. On the discretionary path, every revision brings new review, and the approval clock keeps running in the meantime.

Why the Only For-Sale Project Is Also the Slowest

The Lumberyard was filed on January 31, 2025. The County's file lists 18 condominiums and two commercial suites, and no public meetings had been scheduled as of the page's September 1, 2026 update. Save Pleasure Point reports that revised plans have been submitted for a three-story building with 22 for-sale condominiums, including two to four below-market-price units. The County record may not reflect that revision yet. Under either count, the corridor's only ownership project has been in review for about 20 months and would add around 20 homes.

The small number has a cause that goes beyond this site. In a June 2025 report, Lookout Santa Cruz described how California's Right to Repair Act, SB 800, gives buyers of newly built condos 10 years to sue for construction defects, compared with four years for rental buildings. The resulting insurance costs and litigation risk have pushed many builders away from condos. Some Santa Cruz developers now record buildings as individual condo units and lease them as rentals, the approach taken at Nanda on Pacific and at the Front Street project along the San Lorenzo River. Kathe Head of Keyser Marston Associates, a longtime housing consultant to the city, told Lookout that buyer preferences push in the same direction:

"Homebuyer preferences exist on a continuum, and people want a home as close to a single-family house as they can."

Portola Drive follows the same pattern. State law gives rental housing a faster approval path, and the defect law makes for-sale multifamily housing riskier for builders. The only condo project on the corridor was planned before both of those pressures had fully shaped what gets proposed here.

What the County Numbers Say About Ownership Supply

The Santa Cruz County Association of Realtors does not publish separate figures for Live Oak or Pleasure Point, so countywide data is the closest available measure. In August 2026, according to the association's dashboard:

  • Single-family homes: median price $1,350,000, 111 closed sales, 462 active listings
  • Condos and townhouses: median price $803,000, 25 closed sales, 126 active listings
  • Year-over-year median change: about 3% lower for single-family homes and about 10% lower for condos and townhouses, compared with August 2025

The California Association of Realtors reported a county median of $1,370,000 for existing single-family homes in August 2026. It put unsold inventory at 4.6 months, up from 3.4 months in July.

Twenty-five condo and townhouse sales in a month across the whole county is a thin market. Its median also fell faster than the single-family median. That softness helps explain why few builders risk new for-sale multifamily housing. For a Pleasure Point buyer, it also means that the corridor's added units will change the street, while the homes this buyer is competing for are the same cottages, remodels, and blufftop houses that have always made up the neighborhood's sales.

Questions Buyers Ask About the Corridor

Does a project near a listing change what I should ask before writing an offer?

Ask which approval path the nearby parcel is on, and check the County's Major Projects page for its status. A site in discretionary review can stay unbuilt for years, as Pleasure Point Plaza shows. A parcel with a "-Min" overlay can move on a schedule the County does not control. The proposed timeline for 3501 Portola puts construction in late 2027 at the earliest.

Is anything new opening on the commercial side?

Portola Station at 41st Avenue is in its final conversion phase as a restaurant and bar with patio dining. Save Pleasure Point's September update did not name an operator or an opening date.

Where can I follow these projects?

The County lists Pleasure Point Plaza and the Lumberyard on its Major Projects pages. Save Pleasure Point posts monthly updates on each site.

If you are weighing a home within a few blocks of Portola Drive, Margaret Julien can help you review the parcel records, permit history, and construction details before you set a price. Let's Connect.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Follow Us On Instagram